There is an option at Sean Cody where you can see the list of the most viewed scenes on their site.
5. 66,828 views for Winter Getaway: Day 1 [info]
4. 71,663 views for Shaw & Blake: Bareback [info]
3. 73,210 views for Shaw Fucks Robbie: Bareback [info]
2. 100,011 views for Winter Getaway: Day 5 [info]
1. 121,963 views for Brandon Bottoms: Bareback [info]